Is Your Staff The Problem, Or Are You?

Nigerian business owner and employee discussing a work plan during a performance review.

“I have told her several times, but she still doesn’t get it.”

Perhaps a customer-service employee keeps sending the wrong information. Your sales assistant misses follow-ups. Or your administrator regularly submits work late.

After a while, it is easy to conclude that the person is simply not good at their job.

Sometimes, that may be true. But before you make that decision, ask yourself a difficult question: Have I given this person a fair chance to succeed?

A staff performance review is not just about finding what an employee is doing wrong. It is an opportunity to understand what they contribute, where they need to improve and whether the business is giving them the direction and support they need.

Start With What the Job Requires

It is difficult to assess someone fairly if you have never clearly explained what good performance looks like.

“Handle customer service” is a responsibility, but it leaves room for confusion. Does it mean replying to enquiries within a certain time? Following up on complaints? Confirming that orders have been delivered?

Write down the main responsibilities for each role and discuss the results you expect. For a customer-service employee, that might include acknowledging enquiries within an agreed period, giving accurate information and recording unresolved complaints for follow-up.

The expectations should fit the job, the workload and the resources available. A person handling enquiries alone cannot reasonably provide the same response time when order volumes double unless something else changes.

NUPRC PERMIT

Look at Contribution, Not Just Activity

An employee who is always busy is not necessarily producing the right results. Equally, someone whose work is less visible may be contributing more than you realise.

A sales employee’s contribution might include following up with genuine leads and keeping accurate records, not just the number of messages sent. An administrator may help the business by keeping customer files complete, preventing missed deadlines and ensuring invoices reach the right people.

Choose a few measures that reflect each person’s actual work. Look at quality, reliability, timeliness and how they work with others. Where you use numbers, consider what the employee can control. A salesperson cannot single-handedly fix a product that is unavailable or priced without regard to the market.

Review Evidence, Not Just Your Mood

If you say, “Your work has not been good enough,” can you explain what you mean?

Before the review, look at relevant work records, completed tasks, customer feedback and agreed targets over the review period. Note what the employee has done well as well as where improvement is needed.

For example, instead of saying, “You never follow up,” you might say: “We agreed to contact these ten customers after sending quotations. Our records show that four were contacted. Can we discuss what happened with the others?”

That gives you both something specific to examine. It also reduces the risk of judging an entire month by one frustrating incident.

Ask What Might Be Getting in the Way

A performance review should be a conversation, not a speech.

Ask the employee what they think is working, where they are struggling and what support would help. Then listen carefully.

Perhaps the sales assistant did not follow up because there was no shared record of quotations. Perhaps the customer-service employee has been giving the wrong information because prices changed and nobody informed them. Or perhaps expectations were clear and the employee still failed to do the work.

The answer may involve the employee, the manager or both. Your responsibility is to find out before deciding what needs to change.

Agree on What Happens Next

A useful review ends with a plan, not just a warning or a pat on the back.

Agree on one or two clear improvements, the support the business will provide and when you will check progress. For example, the sales assistant might record every quotation in a shared sheet and follow up within two working days, while the owner provides access to the sheet and confirms current prices. Review the results together after four weeks.

Write down what you agreed and share it with the employee. If performance remains a concern, follow your business’s procedures and obtain qualified Nigerian employment advice before taking formal action.

Final Word

A performance review can help you recognise valuable staff, identify problems early and make better decisions about training, responsibilities and rewards.

But it should also reveal something about the way you manage.

Before deciding that someone is the problem, ask yourself: Did they know what was expected, did they have what they needed, and have we discussed the results honestly?

The answers may tell you what needs to change on both sides.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp

Is Your Staff The Problem, Or Are You?

What If Your Business Apps Went Down Today?

Should Your Staff Use AI For Work?

Are You Ready For Detty December?

Request Consultation

Submit your details below

Consultation Form

Download The

Business Success

Toolkit [Free].

The Business Success Toolkit
Download Form